Research Article
Radiofrequency ablation for snoring and sleep apnoea
Shah Neha*
ENT, Private Practice, Mumbai, India
*Address for Correspondence: Shah Neha, ENT, Private Practice, General ENT /OSA/ Radiofrequency, M Dalvi, St. Eliz, Cumballa Hill Hospitals, Mumbai, India, Tel: +91 9820803214; Email: drnehashah@hotmail.com; clinicalent@yahoo.com
Dates: Submitted: 04 April 2019; Approved: 04 June 2019; Published: 05 June 2019
How to cite this article: Neha S. Radiofrequency ablation for snoring and sleep apnoea. J Forensic Sci Res. 2019; 3: 001-003. DOI: 10.29328/journal.jfsr.1001015
Copyright License: © 2019 Neha S. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Aim
Radiofrequency proves to be a useful tool for snoring/ sleep apnoea cases. Its advantage includes relative precision in incision making, relative bloodless fields if used appropriately, decrease postoperative pain and excellent healing with fibrosis which aids in stiffening tissues.
Radiofrequency is high frequency alternating current used to ablate (cut/coagulate) tissues. It can be applied to nasal turbinates, soft palate, tongue base, tonsils etc. and it can be used to perform various procedures in the cutting mode to improve obstructive sleep disordered breathing.
The objective/aim was to assess efficacy of radiofrequency as a tool for procedures/surgeries for snoring/ sleep apnoea.
The parameters assessed were post-op pain, post- op blood loss, reduction in subjective snoring sounds by patients and partner, reduction in AHI post operatively.
Methods
The procedures were carried out over a period of three years. All cases that came to us had complaints of snoring, difficulty in breathing and sleep disturbances at the hospital departments were included in the study. A total of 25 cases were studied. A thorough history, clinical examination in all and flexible endoscopy /sleep study were carried out according to the case.
The radiofrequency SUTTER BM 7180 machine was used to treat patients. The power settings used were from 2 - 6 in the cutting and coagulation mode.
The procedures were carried out under; local or general anaesthesia with oral intubation and a throat pack.
RF tonsillectomy
Exposing the tonsil on either side, the To-bite radiofrequency forceps or the RF needle was used to incise /open the plane for tonsillar dissection. Dissection was carried out with the same achieving haemostasis at the same time. If properly done bleeding was minimal and pain scores were low post operatively. Fossa deepened and stiffened post operatively. RF setting of 2-3 in cutting mode and 5-6 in coagulation mode was used.
RF Adenoidectomy
Can be performed after retracting lower edge of the palate with tongue depressors or touniquets and coagulating the adenoid with bipolar forceps, the lower edge of the adenoid can be dissected using RF needle or ball point. Bleeding is negligible and wound heals well. There was no case of postoperative haemorrhage. Ideal for recurrent adenoids. RF setting of 5-6 in the coagulation mode.
RF Palate
It is temperature controlled RF volumetric reduction of the palate in order to stiffen or scar the soft palate. The Sutter RF bipolar probe is used to deliver energy to the soft palate at various points. Blanching has to be avoided. The subsequent stiffening occurs over 6 weeks. It was done under local anaesthesia as an outpatient procedure with no bleeding and low pain scores. Subjective decrease in snoring was achieved even in one sitting.
RF tongue base
It is temperature controlled volumetric tongue base reduction by giving RF energy to multiple sites of post tongue base with Sutter RF bipolar forceps. Three sittings of reduction gave a significant reduction in tongue base tissue. There was no incidence of tongue base oedema or infection. The procedure could be done under local or general anaesthesia.
RF up3
It is achieved by uvular and parauvular lateral cuts and trimming of lower edge soft palate with RF in cutting mode and subsequent suturing and tonsillectomy with pillar suturing. The postoperative widening contracture /stiffening helps in achieving a good result.
RAUP
For snoring is done by uvular and lateral cuts, and redefining the post pillars. Tonsillectomy may be combined. It achieves its result due to removal of the redundant mucosa and subsequent healing with fibrosis. Subjective decrease in snoring is achieved by most patients. RF is used in the cutting mode.
Results
Results of the study
| Procedure | No of cases | Pain scores | Bleeding intra op | Postop bleeding |
| Rf palate | 5 | 4-2 pts, 1-3 pts | Nil | Nil |
| Raup | 6 | 4-1 pt,3-1pt | Negligible | Nil |
| Rf tonsils | 6 | 5-2 pt | 10ml 3 pts nil 3 pt | Nil |
| Rf adenoids | 4 | 0-4 pts | Nil | Nil |
| Rf up3 | 2 | 4-5 both pts | Nil | Nil |
| Rf tongue base | 4 | 0-1 all pts | Nil | Nil |
Discussion
Of the 27 patients who underwent treatment with radiofrequency, of the 5 palate cases 2 patients got a pain score of 4 and 3 patients 0-1. RAUP patients had a varied score of 1 to 4. RF adenoidectomy was relatively pain free and tonsillectomy was between 4-5. RF tongue base had very low pain scores. There was no postoperative bleeding in any of the cases. Intra operative bleeding was encountered in tonsillectomy when Rf was used in the cutting mode. RF Palate in one sitting can give a reduction in snoring by 50-70%. RF in cutting mode if used inappropriately can give rise to bleeding issue otherwise not [1,2].
Conclusion
RF appears to be an efficient tool for snoring/sleep apnoea procedures because of
Ability to cut fast and maintain a relatively bloodless field
Ability to cut and coagulate at various settings
Decrease intraoperative blood loss.
Induces fibrosis and stiffening of tissues
Decrease postoperative pain
Other advantages
The instrument /unit appears DYNAMIC WITH A GOOD UNIQUE FEEL.
PROCEDURES CAN BE PERFORMED UNDER LOCAL / GEN. ANAESTHESIA
INSTRUMENTS ARE AUTOCLAVABLE/RECURRING COST IS LOWER
MACHINE IS AMBULATORY
Minimally invasive
References
- Steward DL. Methods and outcomes of radiofrequency ablation for obstructive sleep apnoea. Operative Techniques in Otolaryngology. 2006; 17: 233-237. Ref.: http://bit.ly/2K7aT2L
- Pang KP, Blanchard AR, Terries DJ. Surgical treatment of sleep disordered breathing. Department of otolaryngology, TanTock Sengh hospital Singapore and Dept. of otolaryngology, Medical college of Georgia, Augusta, Georgia, USA.